
By Dr. Leahcim Semaj
Psychologist | Author | Quantum Transformation Facilitator
The Semaj MindSpa — Where Mind, Spirit, and Science Meet
“All You Can Drink” and “Drink Responsibly” on the same poster? Something doesn’t add up.
I saw an advertisement recently that made me stop. The promotion was attractive. Food. Music. Entertainment. A good time. And prominently displayed was one of those phrases we have become accustomed to seeing:
ALL YOU CAN DRINK.
Then, somewhere on the same promotional material, came another familiar instruction:
DRINK RESPONSIBLY.
I read it again. All You Can Drink. Drink Responsibly.
Maybe I am missing something, but aren’t these two very different psychological instructions? One says: Drink more. There is no additional cost. Get your money’s worth. The other says: Exercise restraint. Know your limit. Stop when you have had enough. Which message do we really mean? And, perhaps more importantly, why are we still using unlimited alcohol consumption as a selling point at a time when both the science and consumer behaviour around alcohol appear to be changing?
The Science Has Changed
For years, many of us grew up with the idea that moderate drinking was not only acceptable but perhaps even good for you. A glass of red wine was supposed to be good for the heart. A little rum couldn’t hurt. Everything in moderation. The public-health conversation is now considerably less reassuring. The World Health Organization states that there is no form of alcohol consumption that is risk-free. In relation to cancer specifically, WHO says there is no safe level of alcohol consumption; even relatively small amounts increase the risk of several alcohol-related cancers. (World Health Organization)
That statement needs some nuance. “No safe level” does not mean that one drink will inevitably harm you. Risk is not the same thing as certainty. Risk generally rises with the amount and frequency consumed, and individual circumstances matter. But it does mean that we should probably retire the comforting idea that there is some scientifically guaranteed quantity of alcohol that carries absolutely no health risk. The emerging public-health message is much simpler: Less alcohol generally means less alcohol-related risk. And that creates an interesting problem for marketers.
The Alcohol Business Is Also Changing
Something else is happening. People in many major markets are drinking less. Global beverage-alcohol volumes fell again in 2025 – the third consecutive annual decline – down about 2%, according to industry research firm IWSR. Beer, wine and spirits all contracted, while no-alcohol products continued to grow. In the United States, the shift was even sharper. Overall beverage-alcohol volumes fell about 5% in 2025. Beer declined 6%, wine 6% and spirits 4%. No-alcohol beer, meanwhile, grew 15%.
And money is following consumption. Across 21 leading markets plus global travel retail, IWSR’s preliminary figures indicated alcohol volumes declined 2% in 2025 while value declined 4%. Some of the world’s major alcohol companies are feeling the pressure. Diageo reported FY2026 net sales down 3% and reported net profit down 22.9%, although its underlying operating performance was considerably stronger than that headline number suggests. Pernod Ricard reported FY2026 organic sales down 3.9%, with organic profit from recurring operations down 5.2%. (www.diageo.com)
So we should be careful about declaring the death of alcohol. It isn’t happening. Economic pressure is part of the story. Consumer confidence matters. Drinking patterns differ by country and generation. Some categories are still growing. But something appears to be shifting. People are thinking differently about alcohol.
Moderation is becoming more mainstream. No- and low-alcohol alternatives are growing. Some consumers are drinking less frequently or taking deliberate breaks from alcohol. The alcohol industry can see it. Which brings me back to that poster.
“Get Your Money’s Worth”
Consider the psychology of an All You Can Drink promotion. Suppose admission costs J$10,000. The person who drinks one glass of wine may think: “Ten thousand dollars and I only had one drink?”
The person who consumes six drinks may feel: “Now I get my money’s worth.”
That is not necessarily because either person intended to get drunk. It is basic consumer psychology. When consumption is unlimited for a fixed price, more consumption can feel like better value.
We understand this with an all-you-can-eat buffet. One plate? You barely tried. Three plates? Now you are taking advantage of what you paid for. But alcohol is not roast chicken, rice and peas and salad. It is a psychoactive substance. And one of the interesting things about alcohol is that the more you consume, the more your judgement about how much more you should consume may become impaired. So should we really be designing the economics of the event to reward greater consumption?
Drink Responsibly
Then comes the disclaimer. DRINK RESPONSIBLY. I have always found this fascinating. Who exactly carries the responsibility? Apparently, the consumer. The promoter can advertise unlimited alcohol. The alcohol company can sell the product. The event can make abundance part of the attraction. And after constructing an environment encouraging consumption, we put a small sentence at the bottom: Drink responsibly.
Responsibility matters. Adults have agency. I believe strongly in personal responsibility. Government cannot – and should not – make every decision for us. You decide whether to drink. You decide how much. You decide whether to have another one. But personal responsibility cannot be the entire conversation.
There is also corporate responsibility.
There is marketing responsibility.
There is public-health responsibility.
And there is something psychologists have understood for a very long time: Environment influences behaviour. If the environment is deliberately designed to encourage greater consumption, we cannot pretend that the environment is irrelevant and place 100% of the responsibility on the consumer.
Because the Cost Does Not Always Stay With the Drinker
There is another uncomfortable part of this discussion. If excessive alcohol consumption affected only the person drinking, the argument for personal choice would be considerably simpler. But it doesn’t. Alcohol-related harm can travel. It may arrive in an emergency room. On the road. At work the next morning. Inside a marriage. Inside a violent confrontation. Inside a family budget.
WHO notes that harmful alcohol consumption is associated not only with disease and injury but with family, employment, financial and wider social problems. (World Health Organization) So the person makes the choice. But sometimes the rest of us help to pay the bill. That changes the moral equation.
I Am Not Calling for Prohibition
Let me be very clear. I am not suggesting that adults should not drink alcohol. I am not suggesting banning rum, wine, beer or champagne. People have been altering their consciousness since human beings discovered that certain fruits ferment. And anybody familiar with Jamaican culture knows that rum is not merely a beverage. It is tied into history, agriculture, tourism, celebration, commerce and cultural ritual. This deserves a mature conversation – not moral panic.
My question is narrower. Should we still be promoting excessive consumption as entertainment? That is different. Drink if you choose. Enjoy your wine. Have your rum. Toast the birthday. Celebrate the wedding. But why must unlimited consumption be part of the value proposition?
Perhaps the Industry Needs a New Definition of Value
If drinking habits are changing anyway, perhaps promoters should move with the culture rather than fight it. Sell me a better experience. Better music. Better food. Better conversation. Better surroundings. A memorable performance. Premium beverages rather than unlimited beverages. Excellent alcohol-free cocktails for people who want them.
Let the person who drinks two drinks and switches to sparkling water feel just as much a part of the celebration as the person who continues drinking. The event should be the product. Alcohol should not have to be the event.
And maybe that is where the alcohol industry itself has an opportunity. The future may not necessarily belong to companies that figure out how to make people drink more. It may belong to those clever enough to remain profitable while consumers increasingly choose to drink better, differently – or less.
The Semaj MindSpa Takeaway
I return to the poster.
ALL YOU CAN DRINK.
DRINK RESPONSIBLY.
Put those two statements beside each other and really think about them. One encourages maximisation. The other asks for moderation.
One says: Get your money’s worth.
The other says: Know when to stop.
Perhaps we need to decide what behaviour we actually want to encourage. Personal choice matters. Personal responsibility matters. But so do the choices of promoters, alcohol companies, advertisers and policymakers. If we genuinely believe people should drink responsibly, then perhaps we should stop selling drinking as much as possible as a benefit. Because maybe the responsible question is no longer:
“How much can I drink for my money?”
Maybe it is:
“How much do I really need to drink to have a good time?”
Dr. Leahcim Semaj
Transformational Psychologist
The Semaj MindSpa
SemajMindSpa.com
